Why office space is a ‘primary pain point’ for banks

Big US banks face a challenging environment for office-space loans but the situation is expected to remain manageable for lenders over time, Citi analyst Keith Horowitz said on 29 May in a summary of a recent industry event hosted by the bank.

Citigroup.’s 2023 Beyond the Basics conference highlighted office space as “the primary pain point” in commercial real estate as bankers gathered from Goldman Sachs, Bank of America, PNC Financial Services Group, Charles Schwab, Wells Fargo, as well as Tradeweb Markets.

Topics of interest included asset and wealth management, bank technology, capital markets, commercial real estate, deposits and the regulatory landscape.

READ Top investment banks battle over hybrid working demands: ‘People are just choosing to resign’

PNC’s presentation highlighted office spaces as “the primary area of stress while the rest of the portfolio is generally performing in line with expectations for a slowing economy,” Horowitz said in his summary of the event.

Securitised mortgage data provider Trepp shared similar findings after its analysis of public and non-public data, he said.

The takeaway from PNC and Trepp’s presentations is the belief that “losses will be manageable and more of a ‘slow leak’ than a crash,” Horowitz said.

While bank deposits have been in the spotlight since the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank in March, bank deposits overall remain relatively sticky, according to presenters at the Citi event.

Deposit rates are likely to move higher than expected, Horowitz said, while citing remarks from Curinos, which is an adviser to financial institutions.

About 60% of the money in consumer savings is still parked in savings accounts earning less than 0.25% interest.

Given this data point, banks no longer appear to be facing a shortage of cash to cover withdrawals, Horowitz said.

“The likely headwind for banks has now shifted from navigating a potential liquidity crunch to navigating a tougher profitability environment,” Horowitz said.

Down the road, banks are also facing updated international banking guidelines under the Basel 4 proposals, now expected to be implemented in early 2025. More clarity is expected over the summer on potential Basel 4 requirements such as trading book reviews and revisions to standardised credit and operational risk regulations.

Presentations from Bank of America and Wells Fargo focused on their use of technology and digital banking products.

READ JPMorgan tells senior bankers to ‘lead by example’ and spend five days a week in the office

“Bank of America shared the importance of having a strong digital offering as many of their consumers’ entire experience is through digital platforms; however, the philosophy remains that client needs to drive the tech strategy rather than ‘chasing tech for tech’s sake,'” Horowitz said. “Wells Fargo shared similar messaging as [it] strives to be a ‘digital first, but not digital only’ bank.”

Shares of banks have been under pressure in 2023 after bank deposit runs forced the closure of Silicon Valley Bank, Signature Bank and First Republic Bank and shook confidence in the sector.

The Financial Select is down 6.1% in 2023, compared to a 9.5% gain by the S&P 500 and a 0.2% year-to-date loss by the Dow Jones Industrial Average. Among individual stocks, Bank of America is down 14.5% in 2023, while Wells Fargo is lower by 0.2%, Goldman Sachs is down 3.3%, Citi is down by 1.4% and PNC has fallen by 24.8%.

This article was published by MarketWatch, part of Dow Jones